Candidate methodology 1.1
One Pristine to five Putrid.
This is an ordinal editorial classification of one advertising issue. It is not a probability, customer-star average or legal ruling.
1 · Pristine
No slop found in the completed, defined check.
2 · Slightly Sloppy
A documented detail problem without a central distortion.
3 · Questionable
A material omission, ambiguity or mismatch.
4 · Very Sloppy
Direct evidence substantially undermines a central claim.
5 · Putrid
Enhanced evidence shows the central proposition is fundamentally fabricated or deceptive.
Unknown is not a number. Not rated yet, insufficient evidence, not assessed and outside scope remain explicit null states.